Indie Music

Buy Independent CDs!
Home | Musician Classified Ads | Forums | Sheet Music | Charts   
RegisterRegister   ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages
FAQFAQ   ShopsShops   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups
Log inLog in

Do you think swear words help or hinder the song ?

Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Indie Music Forums Forum Index -> Songwriting 101

If you swear it will sell more records !
A.Yes
6%
 6%  [ 2 ]
B.No
60%
 60%  [ 18 ]
C.Know how to do it in a cool way
30%
 30%  [ 9 ]
D.This topic is really a ____
3%
 3%  [ 1 ]
Total Votes : 30

Author Message
MrsPeabody
Music Forte Master
Music Forte Master



Joined: 05 Apr 2006
More posts by MrsPeabody



0.367 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 8:53 am    Post subject: other countries Reply with quote

Quote:
I was wondering do you think it is just this way in America or do you think it's the same way in Europe as well as in Canado or do you think certain places are better.


To shed some light on this I have a story.

I was in New Zealand a few years ago taking a very long train ride down the North Island. On the train there were many 20-somethings from different countries. They were from New Zealand, Australia, England and other countries. I was the only American. I had not come out and blatantly said that I was American, but I assumed that everyone knew because I didn't have a Kiwi accent or an Australian accent or an English accent. Now, I don't have a distinct American accent like a southern accent or a Boston accent or an NYC accent, but I certainly don't sound like I'm from a country with a distinct accent either. Plus I don't use words like 'boot' for trunk or 'rubber' for eraser.

So we were all carrying on a conversation for a while, probably over an hour, when something came up and I related an anecdote about America. Many people looked at me with wide eyes as though they were shocked that I was American. In fact, they were shocked. An English girl said to me, "I didn't think you were American." in a puzzled manner. And I said, "Why?" She responded with, "Because you speak intelligently." There were many nods of agreement from the crowd at this statement.

Then the group began to put on their best American accents and immitate things that President Bush has said and become infamous for... I insisted that not everyone in American has a southern accent and that many people can speak just as intelligently and even more so than myself. They said they believed me, but their initial reaction speaks volumes about the perception of Americans all over the world.

Now you asked if people curse and have dumbed down their language in other parts of the world. From what I have heard of people my age from other English speaking countries, I would have to say no. I'm sure they curse, but cursing and other unintelligent speech is not what comes to mind when I think of the various people I've spoken with from other countries.

Anyone have any similar or disparate encounters?

Question Question Question
Back to top
More posts by MrsPeabody
Reconsiderate
Forum Moderator
Forum Moderator



Joined: 19 May 2005
More posts by Reconsiderate



96.439 Music Forte Dollars


us.gif

PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 9:51 am    Post subject: Re: other countries Reply with quote

MrsPeabody wrote:
Anyone have any similar or disparate encounters?

I know this one cat from another forum who outright hates all Americans. He has no problem starting fights with and berating Americans at every available opportunity... and he also has no problems creating opportunities to do so.

When asked why, he doesn't have much ground to stand on. "All Americans are idiots. They can't read. They watch stupid television programs, etc."

and honsetly i cant fugire out why him say something liek that because us america ns also talk good in publik forums and have good grammer and no how to spell and also we never type out runonsentences too
Back to top
More posts by Reconsiderate
GregK
Gold Member
Gold Member



Joined: 12 Jan 2006
More posts by GregK
Location: somewhere


34.080 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 9:58 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, I have not been all over the place- really only Canada and mexico as far as other countries are concerned. However, I remember when I studied French I and II in high school that I was rather shocked to learn that most of the European countries- and Canada require that the children learn and speak French, English and either Spanish or German. I sadly have to say that since I have moved into the Raleigh, NC area from the New England area that there appears that many schools in the south are not giving the same level of education that children in the Northeast have received. I actually remember having a conversation with a woman in her late forties -who has been born and raised in North Carolina. we were talking about allergies and she said to me in all certainty that "Flowers give off pollen, but trees and grasses don't have pollen." -now this is something that I remember from somewhere around 5th or 6th grade- so I told her "Im no botanist, but I can safely say that tress and grasses have pollen." Upon saying it- the woman's eyes glazed over and I could tell she had no clue what a botanist was- yet she held a degree from one of the area Universities. Now, I'm sure that over the past few years that education has probably declined everywhere- not just in one particular spot in America, but I seriously feel that other countries are still teaching their children math and science and those kids FAR EXCEED THE US KIDS IN THESE AREAS. I do not have proof for this- so right now this is just my feeling on this matter. I also feel that a bad example is being given to many kids from the welfare system in America- which seems to be showing that you don't have to learn anything- you don't have to get a job.. you don't have to contribute anything and everything can be given to you. So yes, maybe I DO think that other countries do a better job than America. We have it better than many other countries -in so many different ways- just look at your life- or mine..I mean I am on lunch-at my job, I have a roof over my head and I'm earning an income- drive an SUV and just paid for lunch without worrying about the money..many countries don't have that.. WE HAVE ALL THIS- AND WE STILL DON'T REALLY GET IT- A POVERTY-STRICKEN KID IN SOME WAR-TORN PLACE CAN POINT TO A MAP AND FIND WASHINGTON DC OR KICK OUR TAILS AT CHESS WHILE WE SIT IN AIR-CONDITIONED COMFORT WITH A SEVEN DOLLAR LUNCH AND NOT A CLUE. This far exceeds just a swear word or two.. and maybe I need a good kick in the a** for what I m saying- but I'm only saying what I see and what I hear from ALL AROUND ME.. so who REALLY needs the a** kicking?
Back to top
More posts by GregK
MrsPeabody
Music Forte Master
Music Forte Master



Joined: 05 Apr 2006
More posts by MrsPeabody



0.367 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 3:13 pm    Post subject: the real subject here Reply with quote

I think we all could go on and on with stories about the dumb people we've met in this country... and we'd all be hypocrites for doing so because there's always going be something you don't know that someone else does and they're going to think you're a moron for not knowing so...

What the real focus of this thread is is the effect of language used in music, and I think Reconsiderate is right to point out that lack of grammar has an effect on people's general intelligence as well. I have to say that it sounds like nails on a chalk board to me when people use incorrect grammar in speech and songs. It's just proliferating confusion which leads to conflict.

Let me clarify that statement. Many conflicts come from a lack of understanding of words. If someone says something to you using words that you don't understand, you can misinterpret their comment as being an attack when maybe it was a compliment. Or, due to cultural differences, a word/phrase may mean something positive to you while you are deeply offending someone of another culture. This lack of understanding has historically lead to lots of deadly conflicts.

I am fighting the urge to bring up the 'ebonics' issue becase while it drives me crazy to hear people say things like, "we ain't gonna do dis or dat," or use singular verbs with plural nouns or plural verbs with singular nouns or whatever, I can also see the other side of the story where people argue that ebonics has become a cultural language... And it is certainly perpetuated by artists who write lyrics/raps in this dialect...

But when an American goes to another country and speaks this way (or speaks in a language that is littered with four-letter vulgarity), I can also see how they would view that American as less intelligent, and treat them that way. I can also see how someone brought up with lack-luster speech would become frustrated, annoyed and angered by a foreigner who views them as less intelligent based on their speech.

My point here is that there's no harm in striving to speak and write eloquently. In another thread on this site, someone asks, "what gets you going about music." One thing that really gets me is intelligent, unique and eloquent lyrical talent. And that doesn't mean that the lyrics are fully of words that I have to look up in the dictionary (although I did learn a lot of fine words that way as a teen). The lyrics should be full of thoughtfully placed words that express sentiments in ways I myself have never thought to express them.

I'll stop ranting now...
Back to top
More posts by MrsPeabody
Reconsiderate
Forum Moderator
Forum Moderator



Joined: 19 May 2005
More posts by Reconsiderate



96.439 Music Forte Dollars


us.gif

PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 5:36 pm    Post subject: Re: the real subject here Reply with quote

MrsPeabody wrote:
I think we all could go on and on with stories about the dumb people we've met in this country... and we'd all be hypocrites for doing so... I'll stop ranting now...

You thought that was a rant? Man... sounded rather coherent and organized to me. I can't wait until you write something "purposeful" and "intelligent"!
Very Happy
Back to top
More posts by Reconsiderate
Reconsiderate
Forum Moderator
Forum Moderator



Joined: 19 May 2005
More posts by Reconsiderate



96.439 Music Forte Dollars


us.gif

PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 5:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

GregKroeter wrote:
I also feel that a bad example is being given to many kids from the welfare system in America- which seems to be showing that you don't have to learn anything- you don't have to get a job.. you don't have to contribute anything and everything can be given to you.

That's definitely a lesson I've been taught. And let me tell ya... it's been hard to get a job.
Back to top
More posts by Reconsiderate
ChicagoMusicPromotions
Guest




More posts by Anonymous



0.000 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 9:14 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

well like one of my producers told me he has a 4 cuss word limit while making music for people or producing. It devalues you as a artist and also as well only "catures" to a nitch market "ghetto" and or gangsta type of rap, hiphop or hardcore type of music scene.
Back to top
More posts by Anonymous
MrsPeabody
Music Forte Master
Music Forte Master



Joined: 05 Apr 2006
More posts by MrsPeabody



0.367 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 9:39 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
You thought that was a rant? Man... sounded rather coherent and organized to me. I can't wait until you write something "purposeful" and "intelligent"!


You are too kind Reconsiderate, but really, I can't wait until I write something purposeful and intelligent as well.


As for ChicagoMusicPromotions' post:

Quote:
well like one of my producers told me he has a 4 cuss word limit while making music for people or producing.


I think that arbitrary limits on the number of cuss words in a record or song or whatever is a violation of artistic freedom. I don't swear like a sailor on a regular basis, but I have to say that I love that Rage Against the Machine song that ends in a chorus of "F*ck you I won't do what you tell me". That was my anthem when I was 16 and it (and the whole band's body of work) taught me a lot of things about the oppression of people all over the world and a lot of issues that no one talked about in high school.

In addition, I took a little offense to this comment:

Quote:
It devalues you as a artist and also as well only "catures" to a nitch market "ghetto" and or gangsta type of rap, hiphop or hardcore type of music scene.


for two reasons.

Number one, the spelling and grammar mistakes hark back to Reconsiderate's post:

Quote:
and honsetly i cant fugire out why him say something liek that because us america ns also talk good in publik forums and have good grammer and no how to spell and also we never type out runonsentences too


with which I thoroughly agree because those blunders really "devalue you as [/i]a(n) artist and also", as I said in an early post, lead to the general decline of language and intelligence seen rampantly in this country.

Number two, I don't agree that curses
cater to niche markets such as "gangsta rap" or "hardcore". First of all, there are many fine artists who curse effectively (Rage Against the Machine, Bad Religion, Pink Floyd and so many others I can't list them all). Secondly, what is this person implying about these genres?

I can't speak on the behalf of gangsta rap. I don't personally listen to it. If there are any fans out there, you might want to chime in on this conversation. Conversely, I listened to a lot of hardcore in my day and I wouldn't call it a niche market that caters to the minds of people who curse in every other word of their sentences. The valedictorian of my high school was a huge hardcore fan, in a hardcore band and was one of the most eloquent speakers I've ever known. Furthermore, there are many hardcore bands who employ curses effectively (H2O, before they sold out and started sucking, Blood for Blood, ETown Concrete, Strife, Boysetsfire, and I could go on forever with this one as well, but I won't).

What I'm trying to get at here, again, is that cursing in a song or a record doesn't necessarily make you an idiot as long as the words are used only when necessary because there are no other words with the same meaning or emotion to be placed there. I know I'm repeating myself, but it is when they are used out of place that they devalue the artistic work.

It is as if I were to indecorously employ manifold esoteric neologisms to articulate a facile concepts.

Not only would every word be out of place, but this sort of speech leaves a reader/listener scratching their head in frustration while thinking, "what the f*ck did she just say?"

Just curse if you want to curse and don't if it isn't warranted! No limits, no arbitrary numbers of swear words in songs. And no more unfair stereotyping of meaningful music that may not cater to your ear, but represents far more than niche markets.

By the way, can we get a spell-check feature for this forum?
Back to top
More posts by MrsPeabody
ChicagoMusicPromotions
Guest




More posts by Anonymous



0.000 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 10:28 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

lol WOW yes my spelling sucks, and i am just stating in general for example you get a hiphop or rap song where you can count f*** , This Bitch that f*** that etc is not very well. And yes it does de value an artist (personality) it really does show the recording industry what type of person they are.
Back to top
More posts by Anonymous
ChicagoMusicPromotions
Guest




More posts by Anonymous



0.000 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 10:33 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

lol I am just stating in general for example you get a hiphop or rap song where you got more cuss words then music it does devalue them and well they wont make it very far in teh music industry (go ahread) try to market a song to film, tv, radio, or labels that have at least 10 to 15 cuss words in the song and see how far you get. I am not just stating this as a opinion i have heard many good songs with limited Cuss worlds, marylynn manson, korn, NIN, and some others and yes hardcore is a nitch market.

tell me how many gangsta rap artists do you know who have not been shot, banned from performing in countrys or on drug charges?
Back to top
More posts by Anonymous
MrsPeabody
Music Forte Master
Music Forte Master



Joined: 05 Apr 2006
More posts by MrsPeabody



0.367 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 10:49 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

"Let's repeat ourselves
Let's repeat ourselves
Let's repeat our mistakes and never learn to learn from them"

Thanks for proving my point.

Learn to edit...
Back to top
More posts by MrsPeabody
ChicagoMusicPromotions
Guest




More posts by Anonymous



0.000 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 11:03 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I never said spelling was one of my Key features. It seems your kind of bitter about opinions and or imput reguarding cuss words in music.

i am stating fact since i do music promotions when you get emails. phone calls on a weekly basis from film companys, independent labels and other sources looking for music and you send them a song with alot of cuss words in it they need a "radio" edited song and or they dont want a song that has 10 + cuss words in it. - FACT


MrsPeabody wrote:
"Let's repeat ourselves
Let's repeat ourselves
Let's repeat our mistakes and never learn to learn from them"

Thanks for proving my point.

Learn to edit...
Back to top
More posts by Anonymous
MrsPeabody
Music Forte Master
Music Forte Master



Joined: 05 Apr 2006
More posts by MrsPeabody



0.367 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 11:17 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Greetings -- you're missing my whole point that cursing excessively brings down the quality of music and the general intelligence of the population just the same as a lack of grammar and attention to editing perpetuates this unintelligence...

If all you care about is what record companies think -- GREAT! I don't care!

I care about the decline of intelligence due to unintelligent media which you exemplify in your posts with in correct seplling And tHe usE oF ranDom CapitAlization and incorrect grammar

Not to mention that I have to read your sentences several times just to get what you're trying to say because you don't pay attention to these things.

If I were a record company executive, I would refuse an album that was this blatantly incoherent.

And by the way, ending your statement with "FACT" doesn't make it any more forcibly appealing to the mind.
Back to top
More posts by MrsPeabody
djsmooth4lyfe
Gold Member
Gold Member



Joined: 29 Jun 2006
More posts by djsmooth4lyfe
Location: Silver Spring


22.618 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 2:19 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

It could but theres a limit to how much swearing would sell records...too much swearing would not sell as much records
Back to top
More posts by djsmooth4lyfe
GregK
Gold Member
Gold Member



Joined: 12 Jan 2006
More posts by GregK
Location: somewhere


34.080 Music Forte Dollars


PostPosted: Fri Jun 30, 2006 2:30 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Ok, if that were the case then the Sex Pistols NEVER would have made it, or Guns N Roses.. I mean the sex Pistols songs- hell..I remember one song "Bodies" where practically a whole VERSE was made up of the F word! - but then again..they had Sid, so it was cool. I suppose that too many cuss words COULD hurt you- ie you probably won't get mainstream exposure- but in the UNDERGROUND if word gets out that you are making music with TONS of cuss words and every parent hates you and every organization thinks you are evil- you'll probably make a fortune!
Back to top
More posts by GregK
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Indie Music Forums Forum Index -> Songwriting 101 All times are GMT - 7 Hours
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next
Page 3 of 7

Add this topic to your browser's Favorites

 




Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2007 phpBB Group